AGREEMENT
Between the
UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD
And the
International Association of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers
-Transportation Division
(SMART-TD)
UP-Eastern, Northwest and Idaho Districts
Train Service Productivity & Utilization Agreement
This Agreement reflects the parties’ joint commitment to maximize overall train crew productivity and utilization. This Agreement amends the Eastern District Crew Consist Agreement effective February 1, 1992, the Northwest District effective December 19, 1991, and the Idaho Division effective December 5, 1991, and/or all previous agreements and modifications with respect to the applicable rules (if any).
Article I: Productivity and Crew Utilization
A. Carrier obtains the right to eliminate any second train service position (i.e., brakeman/switchman/helper). Carrier may continue to utilize such positions as it deems necessary.
B. There will be no work event restrictions enroute between terminals for trainmen in any class of service. Rules associated with road crews switching at the initial and final terminals where yard crews are on duty or employed are not modified.
C. Any work event rule restrictions pertaining to Foreman only yard and/or transfer crews are hereby eliminated.
D. All right of refusal provisions are eliminated.
E. Assigned road and yard service crew members working as a reduced crew under this Agreement will be paid an additional two (2) hours at the current applicable straight time rate for each tour of duty worked. The rate is subject to general wage increases and cost of living adjustments.
NOTE 1: This payment will not be made if a second crew member is called or assigned to work as a brakeman/switchman/helper for the tour of duty.
NOTE 2: This payment does not apply to single person crew assignments that are working under existing agreement provisions prior to the effective date of this agreement (e.g., positions such as, but not limited to, utility, pilots, switch tender, long fielder, or signal suspension pilot.).
F. Any existing rules surrounding foreman qualification requirements are eliminated (e.g., minimum number of trips.)
G. A conductor/foreman-only crew member will not be censured, disciplined, or harassed if the crew member takes longer to perform work than the time taken by a crew with two (2) or more employees.
Article II – Utility Position
This Article supersedes Article I, Section 8 of the February 1, 1992, Crew Consist Agreement, Appendix A of the 1991 Idaho Crew Consist Agreement, the November 14, 1989 Oregon Utility Agreement, and local Utility Trainperson Agreements dated December 15, 2020, July 1, 2021 and September 14, 2021. The following will govern:
A. The Carrier may establish utility positions to assist yard and/or road assignments or other work that they are otherwise capable of performing along with other duties that are not exclusive to other crafts.
B. Utility assignments will be bulletined for 5-days. Bulletins must include starting time and on duty/tie up location. Carrier may discontinue a utility assignment after giving 24 hours’ notice to the affected employee(s).
1. Assignments may be bulletined with variable work schedules but must have consecutive rest days and not exceed 5 consecutive working days. Work schedules must provide a minimum of 40- hours per work week or 80-hours per two-week period, depending on the schedule.
2. Assignments will be bulletined if the start time is changed more than 2 hours or if there is a change in on duty location.
3. If an extra utility assignment is run out of the same terminal more than four (4) consecutive days, it will be promptly bulletined.
4. Utility Assignments must go on and off duty at the same location and will not layover at an outlying point.
NOTE: An employee will be notified by the end of their shift if the on duty time of their assignment is changed by two (2) hours or less the following day.
C. Employees awarded a utility position may not relinquish their assignment for a period of 30-days. Employees may relinquish their assignment after 30 days but may not bid to another utility position for 60 days.
D. Any assignment not filled by application will be filled by the junior trainperson from the protecting road extra board. Employees force assigned to a utility position must vacate at first opportunity or be subject to Section C above.
E. Extra assignments may be called as needed and as close as practicable two hours prior to on-duty time from the protecting extra board.
F. Vacancies will be filled as follows:
1. Protecting conductor extra board.
2. Combination road/yard extra board.
3. Yard extra board.
4. First out in pool. If multiple pools exist at the location, the most senior employee first-out and rested will be called.
NOTE 1: Make-whole provisions apply to pool employees that fill vacancies.
NOTE 2: Acceptance is required for all vacancy steps above.
G. Vacancies at outlying locations will be filled first by the extra board that protects the location where the vacancy occurred. The extra board trainperson must remain on the assignment for the duration of the vacancy. If the vacancy is known for more than one week, such employee will be released, upon request, at the end of each week. Such request must be made prior to 23:59 on the last day of the work week.
NOTE: Transportation will be provided to an outlying location unless the employee elects to transport themselves. Employees electing transport themselves will be paid the applicable IRS mileage rate from their on-duty point to the outlying location.
H. Temporary vacancies five (5) days or greater will be assigned to the first trainperson with request within the primary protecting extra board location and will remain on the assignment for the duration of the temporary vacancy unless displaced prior to 23:59 of the first day of the assignment. An employee holding the assignment after 00:01 on the second day of the assignment may not be displaced.
I. If an employee is displaced from a utility assignment within the first 30 days, they must return to their previous class of service held prior to being awarded the utility assignment. The time spent working the utility assignment will count towards days worked in previous class of service for seniority movement purposes.
J. Effective with the date of this agreement, the rate of pay is $50.00 per hour. Should future modifications occur to crew size, either through voluntary agreement, arbitration, or Presidential Emergency Board or any other tribunal, the rate will be increased by $5.00 per hour upon the effective date of such future modification. Overtime is calculated by dividing 40 hours by the number of scheduled workdays in each week. The rate will be subject to general wage increases and cost of living adjustments.
Example 1: Assignment A has a 5-day work schedule of 8 hours per day, totaling 40 hours per week. Overtime would begin after 8 hours.
Example 2: Assignment B has a 4-day work schedule of 10 hours per day, totaling 40 hours per week. Overtime would begin after 10 hours.
Example 3: Assignment C has a 5-day work schedule of 10 hours per day, totaling 50 hours per week. Overtime would begin after 8 hours each day.
Example 4:
Example: At Cheyenne a Zone 200 utility position may work up to 25 miles into Zone 400 and Zone 100, but there is no mileage restriction on Zone 200.
O. Temporary Lodging
Example 1: Trainperson Jones assigned home terminal is Hinkle, Oregon. Trainperson Jones is force assigned to a utility position in Spokane, Washington because Trainperson Jones’ seniority does not permit him/her to work as a trainperson at Hinkle. Because Spokane is greater than 75 miles from Hinkle, Trainperson Jones qualifies for temporary lodging at Spokane.
Example 2: Trainperson Jones assigned home terminal is Provo, Utah. Trainperson Jones is force assigned to a utility position in Helper, Utah because Trainperson Jones’ seniority does not permit him/her to work as a trainperson at Provo. Because Provo is less than 75 miles from Helper, Trainperson Jones does not qualify for temporary lodging.
NOTE: For purposes of this Agreement and to be eligible for temporary lodging, a trainperson will be considered “force assigned” when by virtue of their seniority they would otherwise be forced to displace the junior most trainperson at an outlying location meeting the mileage parameters herein.
2. Eligible Trainpersons qualifying for temporary lodging under terms and conditions specified herein are limited to a total of seventy-five (75) stays in a calendar year from the initial time of arrival or until such time the Trainperson is released to return home, whichever occurs first
P. Employees absent more than 15 days will be removed from the assignment. The assignment will be bulletined in accordance with Article II, B and filled in accordance with existing rules.
R. Employees assigned to utility positions will meet FRA operating employee certifications and other minimum requirements and/or training determined by the Carrier.
Q. Employees assigned to utility positions remain subject to mandatory promotion pursuant to Article XIII, Section 4 of the 1985 UTU National Agreement.
S. If required to operate a company vehicle, utility positions will be provided with suitable company vehicle that is properly insured and licensed, for use during their tour of duty. Employees working a utility position will not incur any out-of-pocket expense associated with the operation of a company provided vehicle (i.e., fuel, equipment, maintenance). Utility positions may drive themselves and any other train service employee(s) regardless of position or assignment, as service may require.
Article III – Utility Qualification Roster
Employees working in train service on the date the agreement is made effective will establish a utility qualification date based on their trainperson seniority. This date will be used for awarding utility assignment positions.
Article IV – EOT
When a yard crew is instructed by a yard controller or a manager to remove or install an endof-train (EOT) device in a yard where car repair technicians are employed (meaning on duty and in the yard) each ground crew member of such yard crew would be compensated onehour at the current applicable straight time rate, in addition to all other earnings. Only one payment is made to such yard crew during their shift.
Article V – Overtime for Pool Freight Service
Overtime in pool freight service shall begin when the time on duty exceeds the miles run divided by the controlling divisor, or in any case, when on duty in excess of eleven (11) hours until tie up.
Article VI – Ready Work Board
NOTE: If the decimal portion is less than 0.5, the total will round down. If the decimal portion is 0.5 or above, the total will round up.
NOTE: Alternative electronic methods of contact (i.e. phone text, portal message, et.al.), may be used in lieu of phone contact and considered as proper notification pursuant to this paragraph. It is understood employees may accept notification prior to the (eight) 8-hour period referred to above.
Article VII: Signing Bonus
Note: The signing bonus is not for service performed.
Article VIII – General Provisions A. B. C.
This agreement is signed on 7 June,2023 and effective on 14 June, 2023.
For the SMART-TD:
Brent Leonard Vice President, SMART-TD
Luke Edington General Chairperson, SMART-TD GO-953
For the Union Pacific Railroad:
Maqui Parkerson Vice President, Labor Relations
Naomi Deines General Director, Labor Relations
Jennifer Powell Director, Labor Relations
Questions & Answers
Article I: Productivity and Crew Redeployment
Q1: Does this eliminate the payment to pool freight conductors on Idaho territory who exceed three (3) work events enroute?
A1: Yes, however such conductors shall still receive applicable short crew allowances outlined in previous Crew Consist Agreements and/or modifications.
Q2: Will the two (2) hour payment listed in Section D. be paid to all assigned road and yard service employes who work as a reduced crew (without a brakeman, switchman, or helper)?
A2: Yes, it will be automatically generated for those reduced crews. Employees working under Hub Agreements that allow for foreman only operations or 50% of yard assignments to operate foreman only will also be paid the two (2) hour payment.
Q3: Will employees working in assigned road or yard service who are eligible for a short crew allowance from a previous Crew Consist Agreement or modification receive the two (2) hour payment if working without a brakeman/switchman?
A3: Yes, those employees will receive the two (2) hour payment in lieu of the short crew allowance and/or any existing payment provisions for exceeding three (3) work events enroute. When such employees work with a brakeman/switchman, they will not receive a two (2) hour payment, but will receive any applicable short crew allowance provided in previous Crew Consist Agreements or modifications. Payments cannot be duplicated or pyramided.
Q4: Does assistance from a utility assignment affect the two (2) hour payment to foreman or conductor only crews?
A4: No.
Q5: Do transfer assignments qualify for the two (2) hour payment?
A5: Yes, as they may now be used for general switching.
Q6: Are extra employees who fill a vacancy on a regular assignment that works as a reduced crew (without a brakeman, switchman/helper) entitled to the two (2) hour payment?
A6: Yes.
Q7: Are employees who hold down a temporary vacancy (under the applicable rules) on an assignment that works as a reduced crew (without a brakeman, switchman/helper) entitled to the two (2) hour payment?
A7: Yes.
Q8: Are foreman only extra yard assignments entitled to the two (2) hour payment?
A8: Yes. Any foreman only yard assignment, whether regular or extra, is entitled to the payment.
Q9: Are employees hired after the effective date of this agreement entitled to the two (2) hour payment.
A9: Yes.
Q10: Does Section F reduce the training period for employees to get foreman qualified?
A10: No. This provision only eliminates rules requiring a requisite number of starts or tenure before an employee can enter foreman training. The parties will work together to ensure employees will be afforded adequate training at each location.
Q11: Does this agreement affect the productivity payments made to protected employees?
A11: No, this agreement does not modify nor eliminate those payments. Operations
Q12: Does this agreement affect the $26.00 turnaround provision provided in the July 28, 2017, Wichita-Herington-Wichita Turnaround Pool Freight Agreement?
A12: No, this agreement does not modify or eliminate this payment.
Article II: Utility Positions
Q1: Are utility positions allowed to work independently?
A1: Yes, unless the work performed is related to the switching, preparation of, movement of trains in current operations.
Q2. Does a temporary change to a start time require an assignment to be bulletined?
A2. No. The two-hour window described in Article II, Section B.2 is only to be used on a limited basis. Any permanent change to the start time would require a new bulletin.
Q3: Will an employee force assigned under Article II, D. be eligible for temporary lodging?
A3: Yes. Lodging will be provided to forced employees who qualify under the provisions of Article II, О.
Q4: Will an employee assigned to a utility position be entitled to a meal period during their tour of duty?
A4: No. A meal period is not a right afforded under this agreement. However, the employee may work with local management to allow for an appropriate break during their tour of duty provided it does not cause a delay to operations.
Q5: Can the yard extra board be called to fill a utility position vacancy outside of the calling cycle/bracket?
A5: Yes. Q6: Are pool employees who fill a vacancy required to remain available in order to protect their make whole?
A6: No.
Q7: Are Utility Assignments subject to UP-Eastern District Rule 71?
A7: No.
Article III: Utility Qualification Roster
Q1: Will FITs be placed on the utility qualification roster?
A1: Yes.
Q2: Will employees working as engineers at the time the agreement is made effective be listed on the utility qualification roster?
A2: No. Such employees will not be listed until they are cut back from engine service. At that time, they will be listed at the bottom of the utility qualification roster. If more than one employee is cut back at the same time, they will be listed in trainperson seniority order.
Q3: Will borrow out employees working in territories that are affected by this
A3: agreement be placed on the utility qualification roster? Yes, such employees will establish a temporary qualification date based on their temporary date that was established when accepting the borrow out. Once the employee is released by the Carrier or voluntarily returns to their home location, they will be removed from the utility qualification roster.
Q4: How will employees who are reinstated after the date of this agreement or markup from a leave of absence handled?
A4: Such employees will be placed on the Utility Qualification Roster using their trainperson seniority date provided they work a position in train service upon marking up.
Article V: Overtime for Pool Freight Service
Q1: Are employees hired after the effective date of this agreement entitled to the pool freight overtime provision?
A1: Yes.
Q2: Will pools that currently receive overtime prior to eleven hours under the current
A2: divisor be modified in any manner? No. The current divisor will be used to calculate overtime and employees will receive overtime as they do today prior to eleven hours.
Article VI: Ready Work Board
Q1: Is the Ready Work Board biddable?
A1. Yes. Assignment to the Ready Work Board will be handled in seniority order.
Q2: May employees bid the Ready Work Board when there’s no reduction in manpower that
A2: would necessitate furlough? No. Slots on the Ready Work Board are only available when employees are furloughed. For example, a location has an excess of manpower and there is a reduction in manpower. After the reduction, ten employees will be displaced and cannot hold any assignment except the ready reserve board. Ten slots would be opened and made available to all employees at that location. Employees making application to the ready reserve board would be assigned in seniority order followed by those furloughed in seniority order.
Q3: Are cutback engineers who are working as trainpersons allowed to submit application to the ready reserve board? an
A3: Yes. Any trainperson may submit an application to the Ready Work Board when positions are needed. Slots will be awarded in trainperson seniority order; however, should a cut back engineer get awarded a position on the Ready Work Board and get added back as an engineer, they must return to engine service in accordance with the applicable agreement.
Article VII: Signing Bonus
Q1: Do new hires qualify for the signing bonus?
A1: Employees that have established a conductor’s date on or before the effective date of the agreement are eligible for the signing bonus.
Q2: Are switchman who work hostler positions using their switchman seniority entitled to the signing bonus?
A2. Yes. Any train service employee who works a position using trainmen’s seniority 41 would qualify, i.e., Denver switchman/hostlers.
Q3: Will employees working positions under SMART TD’s Peer Trainer Agreement be eligible for the signing bonus?
A3: Yes, provided such employees would otherwise be working a train service position.
Q4: Are trainpersons who are in FIT training on the effective date of the agreement entitled to the signing bonus?
A4: Yes. Employees holding an engine service position on the effective date of this agreement are not eligible for the signing bonus.
Q5: Will an employee who is in bumped status on the signing date of the agreement
A5: be eligible for the signing bonus? Yes, provided such employee makes a seniority move to a train service position at the expiration of their bump.
Q6: Will the signing bonus be paid on a separate’ check or included with regular payroll check?
A6: Carrier will make payment by way of separate payroll check.
Side Letter #1
Mr. Luke Edington
General Chairman – SMART TD
5990 SW 28th Street #F
Topeka, KS 66614
RE: Implementation Procedures
Dear Mr. Edington:
Since this agreement establishes a new position and qualification rosters, this letter will outline the implementation procedures. It is agreed:
Sincerely,
Jennifer Powell
Director – Labor Relations
AGREED:
Luke Edington
General Chairperson – SMART TD GO-953
Side Letter #2
Mr. Luke Edington
General Chairman – SMART TD
5990 SW 28th Street #F
Topeka, KS 66614
RE: Vacancy procedures at location with multiple boards
Dear Mr. Edington: The parties recognize there are locations where multiple extra boards protect vacancies at a terminal. When filling vacancies for utility positions pursuant to Article II, Section F.1-3, the following steps will govern at the following locations:
Ogden:
Step 1: UY993 XC60
Step 2: UY993 XC65
Step 3: UY993 XK61
Salt Lake:
Step 1: UZ029 XC80
Step 2: UZ029 XC46
Step 3: UZ029 XT50
Step 4: UZ029 XT51
Step 5: UZ029 XK81
North Platte:
Step 1: NX284 XC03
Step 2: NX284 XC02
Step 3: NX284 XS33
Fremont:
Step 1: NX039 XC10
Step 2: NX001 XC01
Step 3: NZ459 XC01
Missouri Valley:
Step 1: NZ459 XC01
Step 2: NX001 XC01
Step 3: NX039 XC10
Council Bluffs:
Step 1: NX001 XC01
Step 2: NZ459 XC01
Step 3: NX039 XC10 7
Denver Terminal:
Step 1: WD640 XC01
Step 2: WD640 XC34
Step 2: WD640 XK01
Step 3: WD687 XT01
For any additional locations not identified herein, the parties will work together to determine proper board order for filling vacancies at those locations.
Sincerely, Jennifer Powell
Director – Labor Relations
AGREED:
Luke Edington
General Chairperson – SMART TD GO-953
Side Letter #3
Mr. Luke Edington
General Chairman – SMART TD
5990 SW 28th Street #F
Topeka, KS 66614
RE: Borrow outs and signing bonus
Dear Mr. Edington:
During negotiations the subject of “borrowed-out” employees was discussed related to the signing bonus provided in Article VII. This will confirm the parties agreement regarding signing bonus entitlements for borrowed out employees.
It is agreed borrowed out employee must meet the qualification requirements identified in Article VII in addition to the following qualification requirements:
Sincerely,
Jennifer Powell
Director – Labor Relations
AGREED:
Luke Edington
General Chairperson – SMART TD GO-953
June 6, 2023
Mr. Luke Edington
General Chairman – SMART TD 5990 SW 28th Street #F
Topeka, KS 66614
RE: Articles III and VII of the Crew Utilization and Productivity Agreement
Dear Mr. Edington,
This is in reference to our discussions surrounding Article III and Article VII of the Crew Utilization and Productivity Agreement and the party’s intent relating to train service employees on a Leave of Absence. It is understood the provisions of Article III, including Q&A number 4, and Article VII are not applicable to employees that are promoted to, or accepted official positions, with the Carrier.
If this adequately reflects our understanding, please indicate your concurrence by signing below.
Sincerely,
Jennifer Powell
Director – Labor Relations
I concur:
Luke Eđington, Gen. Chairperson SMART-TD
May 24, 2023
Mr. Luke Edington
General Chairman – SMART TD
5990 SW 28th Street #F
Topeka, KS 66614
RE: Train Service Productivity & Utilization Tentative Agreement
Dear Mr. Edington,
This is to memorialize the parties’ discussions surrounding the tentative agreement for Train Service Productivity & Utilization. It is understood this tentative agreement modifies the basic crew consist requirement for a second train service position (i.e., brakeman/switchman/helper). Crew size requirements for a conductor or foreman are not modified by this tentative agreement; however, such future modifications may occur through voluntary agreement, arbitration, or Presidential Emergency Board or any other tribunal.
If this adequately reflects our understanding, please indicate your concurrence by signing below.
Sincerely, Jennifer Powell
Director – Labor Relations
I concur:
Luke Edington, Gen. Chairperson SMART-TD